Only the Strong Survive

There's a lot of restaurant competition here in Rehoboth Beach. Some places are just OK, most are pretty good, and a few are exceptional. I promise you honesty and objectivity, so check out the reviews and ratings, then post your own opinions. Click any Ratings at a Glance box to see how we figure the ratings.

"Why does Sea World have a seafood restaurant? I'm halfway through my fishburger and I realize, Oh my God ... I could be eating a slow learner."
---Lynda Montgomery

 

 

Keep up with the news and reviews!
Get the FOODIE DIGEST
by email every two weeks.
Click to register
Clear (32 oF • 0 oC)
Humidity: 79%
Wind: N at 0 mph
Sat 32 ⇒ 49 oF » Mostly Sunny «
Sun 32 ⇒ 50 oF » Mostly Sunny «
Mon 34 ⇒ 47 oF » Mostly Sunny «

Lest we forget! (c)RehobothFoodie.com

'Tis the Season for Specials.
Click here.

*****  Click for News, Events & Gossip  *****

Food 4 Friends @ RIGBY'S Saturday - Click here
Food & Wine Fest @ NAGE Sunday - Click here

Pat's Pizza Opens in Lewes! Click here

Click for WAYBACK WEDNESDAY savings

 
Other Area Reviews - Georgetown, DE

PATTYS_frontPatty Jacobs has been in the restaurant business all her life. When she and her husband emigrated southward from New Jersey, she wanted to open a place where she could serve her tasty sandwiches, salads, cheeses and prepared goodies year 'round, but still be sort of "beachy." Georgetown, the County Seat of Sussex, seemed like the perfect spot.

Word is certainly getting around about this place. I've received numerous emails urging me to visit, and one of my cherished columnists right here on RehobothFoodie.com is a regular customer. It seems like no visit to the Delaware Division of

 
Rehoboth Beach Reviews - American/Traditional

Click to see how we figure the ratingsThe primary thing that used to annoy me about the old Cafe Solé (since revamped and renamed Solé in 2011) was that the portions always seemed small for the price, especially at dinner. And I wasn't the only customer who left there hungry. That's one of the reasons why you're just now seeing my review of this Baltimore Avenue staple, though they've been there for over 14 years.

When Ed and Lauren Cox-Ristenbatt announced their plans to reinvent the food, the room and the concept, I decided to wait and see. And I'm glad I did. (Goodness knows there was enough in 2011 to

 
The Foodie has added updates to the following reviews: Pickled Pig PubKindleFins, Victoria's RestaurantAbbott's Grill in Milford, Nage (including Sunday Brunch), Henlopen City Oyster HousePo'Boy's Creole and Fresh CatchSaketumiDos LocosBack Porch CafeJake's Wayback BurgersPrimoHoagies and Shorebreak Lodge. Check 'em out.
 
Other Area Reviews - Lewes, DE

Click to see how we figure the ratingsOn June 16th, 2011, the Wharf opened under new management with a brand new menu and a good attitude. It was no secret that the old Fisherman's Wharf restaurant was getting a bit long in the tooth. A change was needed in order to take full advantage of that almost-perfect waterfront location in Lewes harbor.

On our first visit, it was a blistering hot day, but the deck bar was overflowing with patrons, music and good cheer. Our most recent visit was on a cold winter's evening in mid-December. The deck bar was enclosed, but (you guessed it), it was

 
Other Area Reviews - Lewes, DE

Click to read how we figure the ratingsOur food and service experiences were always mixed when we ate at Second Street Grill in Lewes. So when Jamie Williams, her daughter Jordan and Jordan's husband Mike Ferger took over that space to open Cake Bar restaurant, we decided to give them a little time to settle in. Jamie and her husband Gene's upscale bakery, Sugar Bakers Cakes, has been a sweet spot in Catonsville, MD since 1996. In fact, this very Foodie used to pick up

 
Other Area Reviews - Fenwick Island, DE

Click to see how we figure the ratingsChef Steve Hagan continues to bat a thousand with his first venture, Off the Hook in Bethany Beach. In fact, it's a little annoying to review, because I can never find much of anything to complain about. But after a couple of servings of that warm, yeasty focaccia, it's hard to complain about anything. So I fully expected the same experience at his second installation opened in May 2011, Just Hooked in Fenwick Island. There are lots of hits, but also a few surprising misses.

So I'll start on an up note with one of the hits: The Sweet Corn and

 
Rehoboth Beach Reviews - Sandwiches / Pizza / Burgers / Fries / Snacks

Click for how we figure the ratingsIt's no secret that Jake's Wayback Burgers is trying to fill the void left by the recent shuttering of the 5 Guys store in Lewes. But Rehoboth Beach is not Jake's first rodeo by any means. The chain's increasing presence on the East Coast, including Connecticut, Massachusetts, North Carolina, Florida, Pennsylvania, Maryland and New Jersey is a pretty good indication that they must be doing something right. I know what you're thinking: "Spare us the rambling hyperbole. How does it compare to 5 Guys?"

Well, first things first, dear reader. Good

 

Tell us your "go-to" dish in the Rehoboth area!
Click here.

 
Rehoboth Beach Reviews - Sandwiches / Pizza / Burgers / Fries / Snacks

Click to see how we figure the ratingsIn 1958, brothers Frank and Dan Carney borrowed $600 from their mom to open a pizza parlor on the campus of their school, Wichita State University. The tiny slant-roofed building had room for only 9 letters (including spaces) on the existing sign, so the hut-like joint became ...Pizza Hut.

By 1973, the operation had grown to 1000 restaurants all over the world. In 1977, PepsiCo purchased the business, and by 1986 had expanded it to over 5000 stores. There were 10,000 Pizza Huts by 1994, and PepsiCo sold the chain to Tricon Global Restaurants which eventually became Louisville-based YUM! Brands, owning and operating 36,000 Pizza Huts, KFCs and Taco Bells in over 117 countries and territories. Hopefully mom got a return on her $600.

It's no secret that the Rehoboth Beach Pizza Hut is getting a little long in the tooth. I always worried a little when I'd

 
Other Area Reviews - Lewes, DE

Click to see how we figure the ratingsAs Bobby Ciprietti and his partners work to expand Touch of Italy into Five Points, the downtown Lewes location continues to pack 'em in. Case in point: I try to schedule my review visits in such a way that I can go a few times during the season and also the off-season, giving me a better idea of how places adjust their service between summer and winter. To that end, my most recent visit to Touch of Italy in Lewes to take place on a cool, late December weeknight. In fact, I wondered if they would even be open. When I called, I was told, "We'll keep the place open for you." How nice. And I fell for it.

Open? The place was packed! People were crowded around the door waiting for tables or to be served at the deli counter. In fact, I had to push them out of the way just to get inside. Was this Katz's or Carnegie Deli in New York? Was this Zabar's on the upper West Side where you have to fist-fight your way to the

 
Other Area Reviews - Ocean City, MD

Click to see how we figure the ratingsOne of the hundreds of online accolades about Grove Market restaurant includes the description, "diamond in the rough." Even a diamond in the rough is still a diamond, and this one doesn't need a bit of polishing. It's just fine the way it is.

Now keep in mind that it's my obligation to be critical and ferret-out things that you might not like about a restaurant. I'm fortunate that most of the places around here are at least OK, but I'm always on the lookout for careless slipups and missteps. So if it was my job to find any substantial fault with the Grove Market, then I did not do my job (I did have one gripe--I'm saving that for later). What I DID do was have one of the most delightful and delicious evenings I've enjoyed in a long time.

The Grove Market was converted from a bait shack (wait 'til you see it) into a restaurant in 1987, and head chef John McDonald joined the crew in '93. He is the very knowledgeable wine critic for the

 
Rehoboth Beach Reviews - American/Traditional

Click to read how we figure the ratingsRegular visitors to RF know that we were less than impressed when JAM Bistro was located in the basement of the old Epworth Church on Baltimore Ave. in Rehoboth Beach. Besides, it's a known fact that people generally don't like to trek downstairs to eat. The food and service were consistently haphazard, and many visitors to RF agreed. Could our perceptions have been altered by the underground gloom?

It doesn't matter, because owners Mark Hunker and Jeff McCracken cleverly moved the sadly subterranean JAM across the street into the bright, amply windowed building that was once home to the storied Camel's Hump restaurant. The attitude, the surroundings -- and the food -- instantly improved. Operations manager (and pastry chef extraordinaire) Danielle Panarello hit the

 
Rehoboth Beach Reviews - American/Traditional

Click to see how we figure the ratingsClimbing the staircase into Planet X is like entering another dimension, glowing crimson from Chinese lanterns that sway in the wind. Pillow-strewn banquettes make even the darkest corners inviting. A purple Buddha peers out at you, his multi-armed grandeur reflected in a mosaic of mirrors that sparkle in the muted glow of ornate chandeliers. "New agey" decor (complete with the obligatory beaded curtain) blends strangely well with the undercurrent of nondescript, soothing (and equally new-agey) music.

The covered porch wraps around the side of the building. On a warm summer's night, it's the perfect place to see and be seen (don't worry--the inside is air conditioned). All in all, Planet X is the most creatively appointed eatery in Rehoboth Beach.

The servers are casual and easygoing, often taking orders without writing anything down. (This can sometimes invite

 
Other Area Reviews - Lewes, DE

Click to see how we figure the ratingsMy most recent restaurant in Maryland was just down the street from a popular crab house and general-all-around seafood joint called Bethesda Crabhouse. Members of that original family have taken over the old Curley's BBQ spot just north of the Nassau Bridge in Lewes and opened The Surfing Crab. They're steamin', fryin' and broilin' themselves into their very own niche here at the beach.

I was a little surprised that their prices on

 
Small Bites
There is absolutely no reason why everyone can't enjoy airline cooking at home.

--Miss Piggy


Vegetarian?
Gastrotourism
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner

Please support our advertisers who help to make this website possible--and tell them you saw their ad on RehobothFoodie.com!
In order to maintain our objectivity, RehobothFoodie.com does not accept ads from restaurants.