Only the Strong Survive

There's a lot of restaurant competition here in Rehoboth Beach. Some places are just OK, most are pretty good, and a few are exceptional. I promise you honesty and objectivity, so check out the reviews and ratings, then feel free to post your own opinions. Click here to see how we determine the Ratings at a Glance.

"Food is our common ground--a universal experience."  ---James Beard

SunnySunny (87 oF • 31 oC)
Humidity: 48%
Wind: W at 9 mph
Wed 62 ⇒ 87 oF » Partly Cloudy «
Thu 59 ⇒ 79 oF » Sunny «
Fri 58 ⇒ 76 oF » Sunny «
Rehoboth Beach Reviews - American/Traditional

Ratings / StandardsNoted restaurant critic Ruth Reichl said it best in her book, Garlic and Sapphires:

"Every restaurant is a theater, and the truly great ones allow us to indulge in the fantasy that we are rich and powerful. When restaurants hold up their end of the bargain, they give us the illusion of being surrounded by servants intent on ensuring our happiness and offering extraordinary food.
But even modest restaurants offer the opportunity to become somebody else, at least for a little while. Restaurants free us from the mundane reality; that is part of their charm. When you walk through the door, you are entering neutral territory where you are free to be whoever you choose for the duration of the meal."

Though Ms. Reichl was making reference to such pantheons of gastronomy as Le Cirque and Delmonico's, this unwritten pact between customer and restaurateur is no less true at any place that touts itself as "fine dining." In Rehoboth Beach, the Blue Moon is one of those restaurants.

It's been a wild ride at the Blue Moon over the last 28+ years. Changes of ownership mixed with a little juicy scandal have brought scattered reports of inconsistencies in quality, presentation and service. But just about every person who criticized this place in the past has made a point of telling me how much they've enjoyed their recent experiences there. Perhaps, in Ruth Reichl's words, the Blue Moon is again "holding up their end of the bargain."

Blue Moon is housed in a restored Victorian beach house where traffic jams between customers and waitstaff add to the noisy, party atmosphere and the sense of hob-nobbing with the "in crowd" (whoever that is). On two of our recent visits, the kitchen started things off with complimentary plates of bacon-wrapped dates stuffed with gorgonzola. The sizzling crisp of the apple-smoked bacon swaddling the earthy dates brought to mind the elusive "umami," or what the Japanese call the "Fifth Taste." In short, I could have made a meal out of them. Go. Try 'em and tell me what you think.

The appetizers set the bar for things to come. The Seared Diver Scallops are cuddled up on a bed of creamy risotto that hints at a salty prosciutto edge. The lucky little mollusks are then showered with a bit of black truffle and parmesan. The Roasted Chincoteague Oysters greet you with the snap of crisp bacon. But wait...after a couple of bites, you detect a hint of licorice: The aroma of anise released from warm fennel! Of course, I had the Fried Green Tomatoes (twice). These crunchy little discs (green Roma tomatoes, I suspect) are presented timbale-style, stacked with a pesto/onion compote. This is not your country diner presentation, dear reader! And, at the risk of annoying the Chronic Complainers, it was delightful.

The star of the soup/salad show is the Wild Mushroom Soup. Notes of sherry give way to the buttery texture of pignoli (pine) nuts, and the restrained spicing allows the woody mushrooms to shine through. Co-starring on that bill is the Organic Mixed Greens. The surprise here is the burrito-like presentation: The salad is wrapped in creamy, thin-as-air strips of Serrano. The chewiness of this dry-cured Spanish ham, sharing your fork with the olives, red onion and Valdeon (a creamy cow and goat's milk blue cheese) sets off a textural party-in-your-mouth. On an earlier visit I also had the Reb Bibb Lettuce Salad with radish, cucumbers and parsnips topped with a pleasantly acidic banyuls vinaigrette (banyuls is a wine vinegar from grapes grown in the Banyuls-sur-Mer region of France). The violin-like tops of curly fiddlehead ferns provided the perfect denouement.

On my most recent visit I went (what I thought was) downscale and ordered the Fettuccini Bolognese. I love Bolognese sauce and have ordered it all over the country. What arrived as a topping for the al dente spinach fettuccine was a deliciously spiced cross between the richest "sloppy joe" filling and the lightest marinara you've ever had. Redolent with red and green peppers, tomato, and what I suspect was a softly spiced combination of lean beef, pork and veal (or at least two--I also tasted fried pancetta, or at least I think I did...), it satisfied both my inner fine diner and carnivore. On another visit I had the Slow Braised Veal Cheek, surrounded by mushrooms and au jus. Ladled over the tender meat was a puree of celeriac (a low-starch, celery-like root vegetable). Oh, and the veal was crowned with a surprise not on the menu: a tiny, sunny-side-up quail egg!

Dining companions ordered the Roasted Half Spring Chicken (simple wild rice and roasted veggies encouraged the crispy-skinned bird to dominate), the Duck Leg Confit (plopped squarely in the middle of the best tasting risotto I've ever had--raisins and goat cheese! Who wooda thought?), and Duck Three Ways with a perigourdine sauce (reduced stock (often veal) with truffles). The breast was seared and crispy, while the leg and thigh were served en confit.

Another member of our party had the Seared Scottish Salmon, ordered (and served) medium with lentils, leeks and a vinaigrette laced with coriander. At the risk of even more hyperbole, she went ballistic. Others had the Slow Roasted Pork Roulade (pork loin wrapped around a textural roller-coaster of shiitake mushrooms and chestnuts), the Braised Beef Short Ribs (meltin' off-the-bone into a bed of chipotle/cheddar polenta), and the seared Rack of Lamb surrounded with a simple array of roasted vegetables.

I do have one complaint; well, really just an observation. As a part of their popular "Tasting Tuesday" prix fixe, the Blue Moon serves a nice little glass of Tawny Port with each dessert that is purchased. That policy is clearly stated on the menu: Order dessert, get the port. Fair enough. On our last visit with a party of 6, five of the diners ordered dessert (alone probably totaling $50+). I chose to "taste around" rather than get a dessert, so everybody received their glass of port, except me. I'll say it again: I do not want anything "for free." Their policy is justified and necessary. But, given that the table probably racked up a $400 check, and everybody had dessert except for one person, that last little glass of port would have been a classy touch.

The Blue Moon is back--with a vengeance. Do you agree? Give them a try, and then post your comments below. They are located at 35 Baltimore Avenue. Always call for reservations (302) 227-6515. After dinner, you can stroll into the famous Blue Moon bar. Depending on your personal proclivities, you could make lots of new friends. (D, Bar). Price range: Expensive +.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Comments 

 
0 # I agree and disagreeTom in Rehoboth 2010-03-28 14:55
I ate there about a month ago and the food was really good, but the service was slow. We did have fun, though, and the waiter was very nice about it. The restaurant is in fact noisy, but I guess that's part of the fun. I would go back in a second.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # You make me hungryCarole S. 2010-03-28 16:19
My husband and I like the Blue Moon very much and most of our meals have been good. I had to write and tell you that reading your review is almost as good as going there! We tell everyone about your site. Thanks.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # We'll try it again!Sue at the Beach 2010-04-26 08:10
Had just about given up on Blue Moon, having had a bad experience about 3 years ago and inconsistent experiences prior to that. Reading your review, we'll now go back.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # I agree with SueTerry M. 2010-04-27 22:54
First of all, foodie, thank you for a beautifully written article. You should be writing for the NY Times! We also had mediocre meals a couple of years ago--too much $$ to spend for "just so." However we have learned to trust "the foodie" and we will go back. The bacon wrapped dates and the bolognese sound so good.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 

Add comment

We reserve the right to edit for grammar, spelling and taste. All submissions become the property of RehobothFoodie.com.
By the way, we weren't born yesterday. It's pretty obvious when a comment is posted by an owner, a disgruntled former employee, or somebody otherwise related to a restaurant. We may or may not post it, but you're not fooling anybody. And we mean that in the most loving way.
DON'T FORGET TO COPY THE CASE-SENSITIVE ANTI-SPAM LETTERS/NUMBERS AT THE BOTTOM BEFORE SENDING!


Security code
Refresh

Small Bites

Every restaurant is a theater, and the truly great ones allow us to indulge in the fantasy that we are rich and powerful. When restaurants hold up their end of the bargain, they give us the illusion of being surrounded by servants intent on ensuring our happiness and offering extraordinary food.
But even modest restaurants offer the opportunity to become somebody else, at least for a little while. Restaurants free us from the mundane reality; that is part of their charm. When you walk through the door, you are entering neutral territory where you are free to be whoever you choose for the duration of the meal.

--Ruth Reichl, from her book, Garlic and Sapphires


Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner

Please support our advertisers who help to make this website possible--and tell them you saw their ad on RehobothFoodie.com!
In order to maintain our objectivity, RehobothFoodie.com does not accept ads from restaurants.