Only the Strong Survive

There's a lot of restaurant competition here in Rehoboth Beach. Some places are just OK, most are pretty good, and a few are exceptional. I promise you honesty and objectivity, so check out the reviews and ratings, then post your own opinions. Click any Ratings at a Glance box to see how we figure the ratings.

"Why does Sea World have a seafood restaurant? I'm halfway through my fishburger and I realize, Oh my God ... I could be eating a slow learner."
---Lynda Montgomery

 

 

Keep up with the news and reviews!
Get the FOODIE DIGEST
by email every two weeks.
Click to register
Clear (28 oF • -2 oC)
Humidity: 88%
Wind: N at 0 mph
Sat 38 ⇒ 50 oF » Mostly Sunny «
Sun 32 ⇒ 47 oF » Rain «
Mon 36 ⇒ 47 oF » Clear «

Lest we forget! (c)RehobothFoodie.com

'Tis the Season for Specials.
Click here.

Rehoboth Beach Reviews - American/Traditional

Click for how we figure the ratingsFormer owner and Chef Michael Stiglitz has long since left the building, but his experienced partners (including his wife) remain. PPP is located in a little strip center on the highway (to the left of Pier One Imports--look for the Starbuck's). This diminuitive beer bar/bar food emporium has made a big impression serving quality eats disguised as bar food--not to mention tons of cool craft beers.

One of my favorite appetizers is  the crispy (and surprisingly light) Fried Pickles. I order them everywhere (including a strange little joint in Kentucky that called them  "Frickl'd Pickles"), and I've had 'em three times already at Pickled Pig. One time they were soft and greasy (fried twice? Mortal sin! Oil temp. too low? Maybe), but the other two times they were fine. Head off disaster by asking for them well done and crispy. The dipping sauce is a kicked-up Russian dressing with a polite burn. My other favorite is the Cuban Black Bean Hummus, colorfully presented with plenty of warm pita bread, bright green jalapeno slices and strips of pickled red onion. It's topped with a creamy white cheese. Filling, but worth it. Go ahead. Share.

logo_PP_smRecently, my party of six chowed down on the Chesapeake Crab Fondue, served with little toast points. It had the consistency of a firm cheesy soup with lots of crabmeat and a hint of Old Bay. Some complained that it was a little thin for dipping, but, after all, they DO call it "fondue." I would have reached across and eaten the whole thing if I hadn't been concerned about revealing that I was raised by wolves. Next time I'm bringing a long straw.

Another diner ordered the "Hog Wings," which are actually neatly cut and well-sauced slices of pork shank. I was threatened with impalement-by-fork if I tried one, so please order them and post your thoughts below (unless I beat you to it). If they're anything like Pig & Fish's pork ribs, you're in for a surprise.

Another unusual appetizer is the B.Y.O.C.B., a selection of artisanal cheeses served with dried fruit and various cured meats. With two cheeses, it's $12. You can add more cheeses for a little more money to make a nice little nosh "for the table." The Asian Bistro Salad is also a star with its citrusy mandarins, cilantro, bok-choy, carrots, peanuts and a spicy ginger vinaigrette. They offer all their salads in both appetizer and main-course portions. Great idea, chef!.

I usually shy away from restaurant chili, but I was assured by our waitron du jour that the Pub Pork Chili was good, and it was, indeed, a cozy little dish for a windy, rainy night. On an earlier visit I had the Cuban Press sandwich (ham, pork, pickles, swiss and dijon on a crispy panini roll). Last night, my preferred dining companion had the Chicken Saltimbocca. My first reaction was that these Pickled Pigs might be reaching a PPP_Waldorf_chixlittle far from their concept, but I was wrong. The chicken was tender, and the little cap of prosciutto was firm and not too salty. It was crowned with melted mozzarella and roasted garlic.

Two others enjoyed the Pub Fish and Chips and the Fish Tacos (same fish, different presentation, still tasty). I had the Creole Meatloaf with garlic mashers, peppers, onions and topped with a moist, polenta-like sweet bacon corn cake and a dollop of tomato sauce. Gush alert! It was REALLY GOOD. Last and not least, another diner had the Thai Red Curried Shrimp mixed with Pad Thai Noodles and a multi-hued melange of julienned veggies and peanut pieces and coconut overtones. She finished it all. The plate didn't even need to be washed.

UPDATE: I have lunched several times at PPP since this review was rewritten, and every time it's been quite good. It seems that these people can do no wrong. The Asian Salad is very tasty, and I especially like the Waldorf Chicken Salad platter [pictured above left]. I will tell you that the plate arrived with soft and warm triangles of pita bread. That's all well and good, but the menu promised nan. No mention was made of the substitution. Did they think I wouldn't know the difference? Really?

Thirsty? They offer 14 (count 'em) beer taps and craft beers are a specialty (see The Beer Geek below). Their 40 bottled beers include some hard-to-find Belgian imports. They also offer "sample" flights of beers.

The Pickled Pig Pub is on Coastal Highway in the Harbor Square Shopping Center.  By the way, Pickled Pig Pub is owned and operated by the same people who have the successful Pig & Fish Restaurant Company in downtown Rehoboth Beach. Though the founder, Michael Stiglitz, has set out northward to expand his empire, both places continue to turn out quality grub and service. The Pub offers daily lunch specials and a popular happy hour. They intend to stay open 7 days a week. Verify that at (302) 645-5444. Click here for a look at Pickled Pig Pub's menu. (L., D., Bar) Price Range: Moderate.

THE BEER GEEK

Without a doubt one of the best beer bars in southern Delaware!! Great tap selection with 14 taps, and more than 50 bottles if you are still having trouble finding something to drink. Here's just a sample of what they have. Keep in mind that their beers rotate frequently, so don’t expect any of these to be there for very long.

Jolly Pumpkin E.S Bam-- What a fantastic "Extra Special Farmhouse Ale" (as described by the brewery) this Saison is! It starts out with some light citrus notes, and just a bit of yeasty funk (that's a good thing!), but ends with some peppery notes and a little bitterness from the hops. Not everyone's thing, but definitely enjoyable.

Dogfish Head Black and Red-- You can definitely tell this brew is from Dogfish Head! A Double/Imperial Stout brewed with mint and raspberry, this 10.5% abv beer is definitely a sipper. Lots of fruit in the nose with some added mint. When you finally a sip it's very sweet with lots of mint and fruit. I would recommend this as an after dinner beer.

Evolution Craft Brewing Summer Session-- A super drinkable, very sessionable brew from the Delmar, DE brewery. It is a light tan colored pale ale that has just the right amount of lemony kick. Would be great on a hot summer day with crabs or at a cook-out, but don't expect to find it in bottles. Only available on draft and in growlers at the brewery.

Those are just three of Pickled Pig's many offerings. Their frequently rotating tap list and substantial bottle list mean you won't have to try anything twice. Look for hard-to-find Mikkeller beers, and also ask about their vintage bottles of Dogfish Head offerings.

 

Comments 

 
0 # deb salvati 2010-02-21 19:20
Gotta try the mussels in belgian ale but be sure to get an extra order of toast for dipping, it is delicious and even better at half price at the bar during happy hour!
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
-1 # Hog 2010-03-16 18:56
Terrific food as usual however, the meal was spoiled by a waiter who was in need of training. He constantly interrupted our conversation by loudly asking if everything was "OK?" I'm sure he was just trying to do his job, but the overkill was maddening.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # Marcella 2010-10-07 20:28
Our waiter came up a bit too much as well, but I guess I would rather have that than the alternative.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+2 # S. Woody 2010-06-08 03:23
The hog wings are, indeed, scrumptious. They are tender, juicy, and coated with just enough sauce to make them finger-lickin' great. They're on the happy hour menu at the bar, as are the wonderfully crispy fish tacos, both delicious bargains.
Another bargain are the monthly beer dinners - five courses for under $40, each course matched with a craft beer. (OK, the first course is usually a cheese sampling at the bar, with three beers offered, but that's a great warm-up for the rest of the evening.) Stigz really streches his culinary muscles with these dinners, which will resume in September.
Bar manager Ben knows his beer, by the way. If you have any questions, he's always glad to answer. Since I knew almost nothing about craft beers before I started going to the Pickled Pig, his help has been greatly appreciated!
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+1 # K. OBrien 2010-09-24 16:43
I am a new owner in Rehoboth and a foodie at heart. Imagine my luck when I bumped into this place my first weekend here, late last year. Tony (our server) was friendly and knowledgeable. Food was excellent and the hog wings were a new thing to me. So tender and literally falling off the bone. Fish tacos, best I have had, but being British I am partial to the fish and chip type fish.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+1 # M Hughes 2010-11-30 11:30
We have been a fan of the Pig since it's opening. Consistently good food, good service, fun atmosphere. They recently changed the menu and removed the pulled pork sandwich which was a favorite Friday nite bite and now serve "frittes" instead of their former, scrumptious steak fries. No pulled pork I can live with but bring back those fries!
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # Vetgirl1 2011-02-21 09:18
Best fish tacos I have ever had, and I have tried them everywhere! Crispy hot tender fish, chipotle sauce with a little burn, soft tortilla...it was amazing. Disappointing dessert, the peanut butter "tastycake". Too much PB, not enough cake and chocolate. Beers were excellent. My date had a burger and was very very happy. Our waitress was friendly and helpful, giving fantastic recommendations . It was a larger space than I was expecting based on the store front size and had a great casual vibe. I'll be back!
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # meatball 2011-06-14 11:36
This place has suplanted Nage as my favorite in Rehoboth.I always order the Fish & Chips and another entree. Last time, char grilled quail over foie gras, crispy polenta "toast points" and some sort of cherry reduction. One of the best meals I have ever had and it was $14. My spouse would also agree that the fish tacos are the best she has ever had bar none.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # meatball 2011-06-14 11:45
Also, I've been to the last three beer dinners and there isn't an empty seat in the house.

Please don't go to these there is nothing special going on there. The beer is barley perfectly paired with the unique, creatively inspired often themed five courses. $40 is way too cheap for any self proclaimed foodie to slap down on a 2.5 hour gastronomzymurl ogical experience with door prizes;)
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # doc martin 2011-07-03 19:07
we stumbled across the picked pig while stopping at starbucks. we walked right bye on our way to the shoe store next store. what a surprise. i only wish dogfishhead had such good food. we go so often now that our daughter doesn't think there are any other restaurants on rt. 1. good pub grub and a great selection of local micro brew beer.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # Martin West 2011-11-30 16:48
So what does everyone think of the new chef?
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 

Add comment

We reserve the right to edit for grammar, spelling and taste. All submissions become the property of RehobothFoodie.com.
By the way, it's pretty obvious when a comment is posted by an owner, a disgruntled former employee, or somebody otherwise related to a restaurant. We may or may not post it, but you're not fooling anybody. And of course we mean that in the most loving way.
DON'T FORGET TO COPY THE CASE-SENSITIVE ANTI-SPAM LETTERS/NUMBERS AT THE BOTTOM BEFORE SENDING!


Security code
Refresh

Small Bites
At the end of every diet, the path curves back toward the trough.

--Mason Cooley


Vegetarian?
Gastrotourism
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner

Please support our advertisers who help to make this website possible--and tell them you saw their ad on RehobothFoodie.com!
In order to maintain our objectivity, RehobothFoodie.com does not accept ads from restaurants.